RDR2’s Milton Was Only A Villain Because Dutch Was

The main antagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, Agent Milton is easily one of the franchise’s most hated characters, but he wouldn’t have that reputation if not for Dutch’s villainy. While the Pinkertons are known to hate the gang and the feeling is mutual between players, it’s very easy to forget that they’re simply doing the job they were hired to do.

Warning: The following article contains spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2.Red Dead Redemption 2The main antagonists of are the Pinkertons, private bounty hunters largely represented by Agent Milton. He is often portrayed as a sadistic man who will do anything to bring these criminals to justice and fulfill his contract, and has quickly become one of the most detestable characters in the game. However, with the status of the leader of the Van der Linde Gang in As a villain in his own right revealed throughout the story, the hatred directed at Milton seems to be a consequence of Dutch’s descent into evil throughout the story. RDR2.

VIDEO OF THE DAY

Related: RDR2 Characters Who Should Absolutely Appear In Red Dead Redemption 3

Red Dead Redemption 2 is skilled in his storytelling at not allowing situations to be interpreted in a singular black-and-white picture, and this is reflected in the way his antagonists are portrayed. While Milton certainly shouldn’t be seen as the hero of this story or incapable of wrongdoing, his villainy is greatly exaggerated by the Dutch, as most of their decisions are morally equivalent to his own. By giving the gang a singular enemy to fight, he distracts from his own terrible actions, leading to the heartbreaking finale as he betrays and abandons those who loved him.


Milton’s Badness In Red Dead Redemption 2 Is Equivalent To Dutch’s

After cruelly murdering a girl during the events of the Blackwater Massacre before RDR2, Dutch constantly tries to evade the gang’s questions by diverting their attention. And the defamation of Agent Milton and his associates is no different. Although both players and Arthur may believe him unconditionally at first, his actions are later revealed to be just as bad as the Pinkertons’ as his plans sour and he grows closer to Micah. Throughout the game, Dutch becomes embroiled in a greedy quest for power and money, taking those loyal to him and later dumping them on a whim. But, bringing the gang’s attention to another’s terrible actions, it takes a long time for them to be held accountable for their own and for their true colors to be seen.


RDR2 doesn’t portray Dutch’s glory days so much as it reveals the decisions he made without regard for the safety of others, such as abandoning Arthur and allowing Micah’s allies to kill Mrs. Grimshaw. Dutch and Milton serve the same purpose in the story: to destroy the gang. As Milton does this from the outside – killing, torturing and arresting gang members – Dutch does the same from the inside by continually indulging in selfish interests. They are incredibly similar men, both willing to do anything to achieve their goals, no matter the cost, but for different reasons. Because of this, Milton’s irredeemable villainy often turns out to be incredibly over the top.


Red Dead Redemption 2 is incredibly unique, establishing a moral spectrum for the protagonist that is reflected in each character. Even his antagonists make sense, with Agent Milton’s own narrative advancing the story as he becomes a tool for developing other characters. Even though red dead online is completely dead, Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of the best sequels Rockstar has ever made, with a powerful story exploring well-developed themes.